Skip to main content
Feed the Future
This project is part of the U.S. Government's global hunger and food security initiative.
  • About
subscribe

Agrilinks

Search Log In

Main Menu

  • Topics
  • Events
  • Activities
  • Tools & Training
  • Members
  • About
subscribe

Reflections on Impactful Design: Introducing the AgResults Pay-for-Results Prize Competition Toolkit

AgResults Initiative

Mar 25, 2021
Five phases of AgResults prize design

How do we best structure an advance market commitment for agriculture? How do we incentivize the private sector to solve problems faced by the majority of the poorest people on Earth: smallholder farmers?

The $152 million AgResults initiative — with the support of British, Australian, Canadian, and American aid agencies as well as the Gates Foundation and facilitated by the World Bank — is unique. It manages to be both a complex multidonor fund that facilitates multilateral coordination and learning and a very flexible initiative that can turn on a dime. Our secretariat, run to date by Deloitte, has collected the feedback and facilitated the frank conversations necessary to do this.

In 2016, AgResults launched one of the largest-ever humanitarian prizes, the $30 million Brucellosis vaccine prize. Four years later, we had more than a dozen competitors striving to design a novel best-in-class vaccine, but we are no more certain if the prize will be claimed by its ten-year finish line. AgResults has had two clearly failed projects, focused on legume seeds in Uganda and biofortified maize in Zambia, and two that have clearly jump-started products critical to smallholders, Aflasafe in Nigeria and on-farm storage in Kenya. In addition to the Brucellosis vaccine prize, there are five ongoing pay-for-results efforts: reducing greenhouse gas emissions in Vietnam, improving dairy production in Tanzania, making aquaculture in Indonesia more efficient, enhancing collective crop storage in Senegal and distributing an improved Foot and Mouth Disease vaccine across East Africa.

From the start, our purpose was to set up AgResults as a learning initiative and the compilation of a toolkit was part of that intention. One of the reasons pay-for-results mechanisms are not more widely used is that they are admittedly hard to design. And getting the design right is crucial as it is hard to equitably shift competition rules after they are announced.

We humbly recognize that how-to documents in the development space can feel dense, so we have tried to make these pages engaging. But if you are considering designing a pay-for-performance mechanism, prize, proportional prize or advance market commitment (AMC) in the development space and would like to review anything covered here, we’d love to touch base with you.

Best of luck in your efforts!

Filed Under: Agricultural Productivity Food Safety Markets and Trade Resilience

Comments

Related Resources

Impactful Design - AgResults Pay-for-Results Prize Competition Toolkit.pdf3.05 MB

You May Also Like

post

Fueling the Nigerian Maize Sector with a Pay-for-Results “Nudge”

You can’t see or smell them, but aflatoxins are one of the world’s most carcinogenic substances. They are produced by a group of molds known as the Aspergillus fungi that...

Agrilinks Team

Jun 04, 2019
post

A New Way to Boost Dairy Productivity in Tanzania

Although the demand for fresh milk in Tanzania is growing, the local dairy value chain isn’t keeping up. The upcoming AgResults Tanzania Dairy Productivity Challenge Project could be the key...

Agrilinks Team

Nov 18, 2019
post

At the Crossroads of Inclusion and Growth: Blending Prizes with ICTforAg in Tanzania

AgResults’ Pay-for-Results model, which engages the private sector through prize competitions, may provide a unique path to tackling the common development challenges of inclusion and economic growth.

Parasto Hamed

Jan 21, 2021
post

Gender Mainstreaming in Fisheries and Aquaculture Sectors

The Fish Innovation Lab uses a framework adapted from Kleiber and colleagues to identify gender barriers specific to fisheries and aquaculture sectors.

Agrilinks Team

Mar 29, 2021
Follow Agrilinks:
  • Youtube
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • RSS
Agrilinks
Achieving agriculture-led food security through knowledge sharing
MarketLinks
Market-based solutions for development
LearningLab
A collaborative learning community of development professionals
Landlinks
USAID's knowledge sharing platform focused on land tenure and property rights
Climatelinks
A global knowledge portal for climate change & development practitioners
Urbanlinks
USAID’s sharing platform for resources on sustainable urban development
Resiliencelinks
A global knowledge platform for resilience practitioners
Globalwaters
Sharing knowledge and ideas to solve global water and sanitation challenges
U.S. Agency for International Development
  • Accessibility
  • Contact
  • Help
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
The information provided on this website is not official U.S. government information and does not represent the views or positions of the U.S. Agency for International Development or the U.S. Government.

Search Agrilinks

My Account

  • My drafts and published content
  • My profile
Sign out

Contribute To Agrilinks

  • Add a post
  • Add an event
Need help?

Subscribe

Subscribe to receive our weekly newsletter featuring the latest and greatest Agrilinks content.

You'll also receive invitations to upcoming Agrilinks webinars and other special announcements. We won't share your email address and you can unsubscribe at any time.